After 10 years of robots milking their cows, Simpson farmers Symone and Phil Vines look well beyond the milk vat to assess their return on investment.
How do you calculate the value of an extra three hours sleep a day, or being able to take the kids to football, cricket or basketball without having to worry about being home for the evening milking?
And what about the wear and tear on their bodies?
“There have been millions of shoulder movements we haven't done, thousands of hours not spent standing on concrete,” Symone says.
Phil and Symone were among the first farmers in south-west Victoria to install robots.
At the time, the installation of the four Lely A4 robots came out of necessity.
“We had to build a new dairy, the old one was literally falling apart,” Symone said.
“We went to the bank manager to ask about finance for a herringbone - he suggested we look at robots.
“We set off to look at a few in Gippsland to rule them out but once we saw the cows in the system, it was clear that's what Phil wanted.
The cows were so quiet and docile. Training the cows was much easier than we expected once they discovered there was food in the robot.
“We loved the concept of the cows being truly free range.
“Some days we only collect a handful of cows, some days we collect none, some days 30. If we over allocate, we are collecting more – they’re living their best life down the paddock.
“The cows are very quiet and I often have to try to physically move them to walk through the yard.
“The fresh cows can really shine - milking 4 times a day if they choose. The later lactation cows can milk once or twice and they can rest a little more.”
Symone’s favourite part is watching cows walk opposite directions on a narrow laneway.
“They don't care - they have somewhere to be. We know them as herd animals but when they run the system, they happily go their own way. The only time they're a herd animal here is if someone has left the gate open.”
The cows are continuing to produce well, 640 kg/Ms with Symone and Phil aiming for 700 kilos.
“Solids have always been very good, we want to look for litres now,” she said.
They have very few lameness issues.
Symone and Phil bought their first cow in 2009, naming her Hope. They were self-starters, with no family farm or family money and help.
They bought a herd with little history available from a corporate farm and paid them off over five years. They bought their farm in 2013, adding the robots in 2016.
“After Murray Goulburn did what they did we had to run two farms for years to keep our head above water and even worked part-time off farm as well,” Symone said.
Finding it difficult to get full-time staff, they run the farm as a husband-and-wife team, with only part- time staff for cleaning on limited hours.
They have 121ha, though not all usable, on the home farm with more than 380 animals on farm at the moment.
They have another 166ha used for young stock and beef.
The herd is a mix of Holsteins with Jerseys and Normande.
“We get up to milking 300 cows, but we are trying to get down to 230.
“We were cow parking 17 full blood Normandes for a friend and I fell in love with them,” Symone said.
“We now have close to 40 full blood Normandes on farm.”
They calve three times a year with sexed semen given to the absolute best animals. They have been genomic testing since 2014.
“Normande is joined to Normande, Jersey to Jersey, Holstein to Holstein - Phil is very particular about this,” Symone said.
The rest of the herd get beef - Angus or Danish blue.
“We keep and rear everything; our beef herd is made up of about 150 animals of varying ages right now,” she said.
When breeding, they look for longevity, feed efficiency, litres, solids, milk quality.
In the usually high rainfall area of Simpson, they grow multispecies crops in the grazing paddocks and summer crops, and also cut and carry during May to September.
“We estimate this has doubled our grass growth on these paddocks - the density is much greater,” Symone said.
“Our system is hybrid, cows can be housed or graze, so we do both 95 per cent of the year. It's only when it's really hot or very wet that we house them for more than 24 hours.”
They feed silage, grain and hay in mixer wagon and the rest is grazed.
So far, this season has been very kind with silage cut earlier than ever, though they are a bit worried that the rain has now stopped.
They didn’t have to make major changes during the drought.
“We sold a few that really needed to go anyway,” Symone said.
“It's hard for cows to hide in this system - with daily herd test information available.”
However, it was a tough time.
“We had just put in a new loafing barn when the drought hit so financially it was very tough again.
“We have long and great relationships with local businesses, agronomist, nutritionist and our hay supplier and we relied on these relationships heavily. It was the most stressed I had felt since April 2016.
“We were thankful we weren't buying $750 tonne fodder, I'm not sure how we would have coped with that.”
Symone and Phil haven’t needed to upgrade their robots.
“We don't want to add more robots because we want to milk less cows and get the same production - we have no interest in getting bigger.
“We don't measure success by milking more animals; we measure success by milking efficient animals, making a profit and having a life.
“We look after the robots very well and they are serviced by South West Dairy Service. We've found if you look after the robots - they will look after you.”
Symone believes they were the first in the region to install robots and make them work.
“I don't know if people had unrealistic expectations or service issues, we had neither because we knew they worked.
“We knew they would be a big tie and we would be on call 24 hours and we also knew it would take a lot of adjustment for us and the cows.”
Symone’s advice is simple.
“If you love milking cows and you're not ready to get out definitely consider robots but be realistic.”